Jump to content
Mander Organs
Sign in to follow this  
Martin Cooke

Francis Jackson query

Recommended Posts

I wonder if anyone can solve a quick mystery! Having read somewhere that FJ's favourite own composition was his Impromptu for Bairstow's 70th birthday, I sought it out on itunes. There appear to be two pieces with the same or a similar name - the one recorded by John Scott Whiteley is the piece I was expecting from what I remember of the score in the York Organ Album. However, there is a second piece called Impromptu for Edward Bairstow's 70th on a recording by FJ which is not the same piece at all. I don't suppose that FJ wrote two different Impromptus for EB - could anyone have a quick listen to the snippet on their itunes account and tell me what the piece is on the FJ recording that may incorrectly be labelled Impromptu for EB? Sorry, I've made this sound laborious.

Martin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wonder if anyone can solve a quick mystery! Having read somewhere that FJ's favourite own composition was his Impromptu for Bairstow's 70th birthday, I sought it out on itunes. There appear to be two pieces with the same or a similar name - the one recorded by John Scott Whiteley is the piece I was expecting from what I remember of the score in the York Organ Album. However, there is a second piece called Impromptu for Edward Bairstow's 70th on a recording by FJ which is not the same piece at all. I don't suppose that FJ wrote two different Impromptus for EB - could anyone have a quick listen to the snippet on their itunes account and tell me what the piece is on the FJ recording that may incorrectly be labelled Impromptu for EB? Sorry, I've made this sound laborious.

Martin

 

I think there's an error on the digital format of the FJ album - the same mis-labelling of the track in question occurs on Spotify. (But off hand I can't remember which piece this actually is!)

 

The Impromptu is definitely the piece played by JSW in Sheffield City Hall.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wonder if anyone can solve a quick mystery! Having read somewhere that FJ's favourite own composition was his Impromptu for Bairstow's 70th birthday, I sought it out on itunes. There appear to be two pieces with the same or a similar name - the one recorded by John Scott Whiteley is the piece I was expecting from what I remember of the score in the York Organ Album. However, there is a second piece called Impromptu for Edward Bairstow's 70th on a recording by FJ which is not the same piece at all. I don't suppose that FJ wrote two different Impromptus for EB - could anyone have a quick listen to the snippet on their itunes account and tell me what the piece is on the FJ recording that may incorrectly be labelled Impromptu for EB? Sorry, I've made this sound laborious.

Martin

 

 

==========================

 

 

I have the copy of the Impromptu as originally published, with the EB dedication included.

 

It's the one where the (very beautiful) tune starts with F# G A F# D E F# I think, but I haven't checked to make sure.

 

 

MM

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
However, there is a second piece called Impromptu for Edward Bairstow's 70th on a recording by FJ which is not the same piece at all.

 

It could simply be a mislabelling of CD track; such things are known to happen from time to time.

 

There is a listing of FJ's complete works (albeit last updated five years ago) on the York Minster website, as follows:

http://www.yorkminster.org/documents/downloads229.pdf

 

As far as can be seen, there's only the one Impromptu, duly dedicated to ECB on his 70th birthday.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
However, there is a second piece called Impromptu for Edward Bairstow's 70th on a recording by FJ which is not the same piece at all.

 

It could simply be a mislabelling of CD track; such things are known to happen from time to time.

 

There is a listing of FJ's complete works (albeit last updated five years ago) on the York Minster website, as follows:

http://www.yorkminster.org/documents/downloads229.pdf

 

As far as can be seen, there's only the one Impromptu, duly dedicated to ECB on his 70th birthday.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's a mislabelled track. I fell into the same trap.

If you buy the track labelled Sonata Giocosa Op 62: Cadenza (Track 11 of the same CD) you'll have the Bairstow Impromptu.

It's published in the Fanfare for Francis album put out by Banks in 2007 - which comes with a recording of JSW playing it at the Minster.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many thanks everyone - so I presume that the title of the first piece I downloaded is actually that of the track before - ? I have the Impromptu in print (York Album and Fanfare for Francis) and also recorded.

Martin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...